- I Am A Poor Wayfaring StrangerRichard W. Adams
- I Am Coming To The CrossWilliam Gustavus Fischer
- I Am His, And He Is MineGeorge Wade Robinson
- I Am Not Skilled To UnderstandDorothy (Dora) Greenwell
- I Am Praying For YouSamuel O'Malley Gore Cluff
- I Am ResolvedPalmer Hartsough
- I Am So Glad Each Christmas EveInger Marie Lycke Wexelsen
- I Am So Glad Salvation's FreeJames Rowe
- I Am Thine, O LordFrances Jane (Fanny) Crosby
- I Am Trusting TheeFrances Ridley Havergal
- I Asked The Lord That I Might GrowJohn Newton
- I Belong To The KingJoseph Lincoln Hall
- I Bow My Forehead To The DustJohn Greenleaf Whittier
- I Cannot Tell Why
- I Choose JesusJames Rowe
- I Could Not Do Without TheeFrances Ridley Havergal
- I Cried To God In My Distress
- I Do Not Ask, O LordAdelaide Ann Procter
- I Do Not Know HowHelen Howarth Lemmel
- I Dreamed That The Great Judgment Morning
- I Feel The Winds Of God TodayJessie Adams
- I Gave My Life For TheeFrances Ridley Havergal
- I Greet Thee, Who My Sure Redeemer Art
- I Have A SaviorRobert Harkness
- I Have Entered Beulah LandFrances Jane (Fanny) Crosby
- I Have Found A Precious Resting PlaceHaldor Lillenas
- I Have Settled The QuestionHaldor Lillenas
- I Hear Ten Thousand Voices SingingHenry Watson Fox
- I Hear Thy Welcome VoiceLewis Hartsough
- I Heard A Sound Of VoicesGodfrey Thring
- I Heard The Bells On Christmas DayJohn Baptiste Calkin
- I Heard The Voice Of Jesus SayHoratius Bonar
- I Know Not How That Bethlehem's BabeHarry Webb Farrington
- I Know Of A NameMabel Johnston Camp
- I Know That My Redeemer Lives (1)Samuel Medley
- I Know That My Redeemer Lives (2)Charles Wesley
- I Know That My Redeemer LivethJessie Brown Pounds
- I Know That Some DayAlbert Simpson Reitz
- I Know Whom I Have BelievedDaniel Webster Whittle
- I Lay My Sins On JesusHoratius Bonar
- I Left It All With JesusIra D. Sankey
- I Lift My Banner, Saith The LordIsaac Watts
- I Lift My Heart To Thee
- I Look To Thee In Every NeedSamuel Longfellow
- I Love JesusEliza Edmunds Stites Hewitt
- I Love My Jesus Quite Alone
- I Love The Lord, He Heard My VoiceJoseph Proud
- I Love The Lord, His Strength Is Mine
- I Love The Voice DivineJoseph Proud
- I Love Thee
- I Love Thy Kingdom, LordTimothy Dwight
- I Love To Hear The StoryEmily Huntington Miller
- I Love To Steal Awhile AwayPhoebe Hinsdale Brown
- I Love To Tell The StoryArabella Katherine Hankey
- I Love To Walk With Jesus
- I Must Tell JesusElisha Albright Hoffman
- I Need Thee Every HourAnnie Sherwood Hawks
- I Need Thee, Precious JesusFrederick Whitfield
- I Remember When My Burdens Rolled Away
- I Saw One Hanging On A TreeJohn Newton
- I Saw The Cross Of JesusFrederick Whitfield
- I Saw Three Ships Come Sailing InRichard W. Adams
- I Say To All Men Far And NearCatherine Winkworth
- I Shall Not Be Afraid Psalm 56:3-4; Psalm 121 (NIV)
- I Sing The Mighty Power Of GodIsaac Watts
- I Sought The LordGeorge Whitefield Chadwick
- I Stand Amazed In The PresenceCharles Hutchinson Gabriel
- I Surrender AllJudson Wheeler Van DeVenter
- I Think, When I Read That Sweet StoryJemima Thompson Luke
- I To The Hills Will Lift My Eyes
- I Vow To Thee, My CountryCecil Spring-Rice
- I Waited For The Lord Most HighJoseph Barnby
- I Walk The King's HighwayHenry W. Greatorex
- I Walk With The KingJames Rowe
- I Wandered In The Shades Of NightJudson Wheeler Van DeVenter
- I Want A Principle WithinCharles Wesley
- I Was A Wandering SheepHoratius Bonar
- I Was Made A Christian
- I Will Ever Sing Thy PraisesJustin Heinrich Knecht
- I Will Make The Darkness LightCharles Price Jones
- I Will Not Be AfraidEllis Govan
- I Will Not Forget TheeCharles Hutchinson Gabriel
- I Will Praise HimMargaret Jenkins Harris
- I Will Sing My Maker's PraisesPaul Gerhardt
- I Will Sing The Wondrous StoryFrancis Harold Rowley
- I Will Sing You A SongEllen Maria Huntington Gates
- I Would Be Like JesusJames Rowe
- I Would Be TrueHoward Arnold Walter
- I'll Be A SunbeamEdwin Othello Excell
- I'll Bear It Lord, For TheeFrances Jane (Fanny) Crosby
- I'll Go Where You Want Me To GoIra D. Sankey
- I'll Live For HimRalph E. Hudson
- I'll Not Give Up The BibleWilliam Thomas Giffe
- I'll Overcome Some DayCharles Albert Tindley
- I'll Praise My MakerIsaac Watts
- I'm But A Stranger HereThomas Rawson Taylor
- I'm Going ThereCharles Austin Miles
- I'm Going ThroughHerbert Buffum
- I've A Message From The LordWilliam Augustine Ogden
- I've Anchored In JesusLewis Ellis Jones
- I've Believed The True ReportCharles Price Jones
- I've Found A FriendJames Grindlay Small
- I've Found A RefugeAvis Marguerite Burgeson Christiansen
- I've Found The Pearl Of Greatest PriceJohn Mason
- I've Got Peace Like A River
- I've Pitched My Tent In BeulahMargaret Jenkins Harris
- If Christ Is MineBenjamin Beddome
- If Jesus Goes With MeCharles Austin Miles
- If Tonight Should End The World
- If You Will Only Let God Guide YouGeorg Neumark
- If, On A Quiet SeaAugustus Montague Toplady
- Immanuel, We Sing Thy PraisePaul Gerhardt
- Immortal Love, Forever FullJohn Greenleaf Whittier
- Immortal, Invisible, God Only WiseWalter Chalmers Smith
- Impatient Heart, Be StillGeorge Coles Stebbins
- In A Manger Laid So LowlyWilliam Batchelder Bradbury
- In Age And Feebleness ExtremeCharles Wesley
- In Boundless MercyEmanuel Swedenborg
- In Christ There Is No East Or WestWilliam Arthur Dunkerley
- In Evil Long I Took DelightJohn Newton
- In Gethsemane Alone
- In Grief And Fear, To Thee, O LordWilliam Bullock
- In Heavenly Love AbidingAnna Laetitia Waring
- In His Temple God Be Praised
- In Lovingkindness Jesus CameCharles Hutchinson Gabriel
- In One True God We All BelieveJuraj Tranovsk²
- In Sin I Once Had WanderedKate Ulmer
- In Stature Grows The Heavenly ChildJean Baptiste de Santenil
- In Tenderness He Sought MeAdoniram Judson Gordon
- In The Bleak MidwinterChristina Georgina Rossetti
- In The Child GardenJulia Harriet Johnston
- In The Cross Of Christ I GloryJohn Bowring
- In The Family Of GodRobert Edward William Cottrill
- In The Field With Their Flocks AbidingFrederic William Farrar
- In The GardenCharles Austin Miles
- In The Hollow Of His HandSamuel W. Beazley
- In The Hour Of TrialJames Montgomery
- In The Lonely MidnightTheodore Chickering Williams
- In The Morning I Will RaiseWilliam Henry Furness
- In The Secret Of His PresenceEllen Lakshmi Goreh
- In The Service Of The KingAlfred Henry Ackley
- In The Sweet By And BySanford Fillmore Bennett
- In The Twinkling Of An EyeFrances Jane (Fanny) Crosby
- In The Vineyard Of Our FatherThomas MacKellar
- In Thee Is GladnessCatherine Winkworth
- In Thy Name, O Lord, AssemblingThomas Kelly
- In Thy Wrath And Hot DispleasureJohn Bacchus Dykes
- In Time Of TribulationJames Montgomery
- Infant Holy, Infant LowlyEdith Margaret Gellibrand Reed
- Infinite God, To Thee We RaiseCharles Wesley
- Into The WoodsSidney Clopton Lanier
- Into Thy Gracious Hands I FallJohn Wesley
- Is It For Me?Frances Ridley Havergal
- Is It The Crowning Day?Henry Ostrom
- Is It There?Frances Jane (Fanny) Crosby
- Is My Name Written There?Mary Ann Pepper Kidder
- Is There A Heart Bent O'er With Sorrow?Edward Henry Joy
- Is Thy Heart Right With God?Elisha Albright Hoffman
- Is Your All On The Altar?Elisha Albright Hoffman
- It Came Upon The Midnight ClearEdmund Hamilton Sears
- It Fell Upon A Summer DayStopford Augustus Brooke
- It Is FinishedGabriel Gillett
- It Is Glory Just To Walk With HimAvis Marguerite Burgeson Christiansen
- It Is Good To Sing Thy PraisesWolfgang Amadeus Mozart
- It Is Truly Wonderful
- It Is Well With My SoulHoratio Gates Spafford
- It May Not Be Our LotJohn Greenleaf Whittier
- It Pays To Serve JesusFrank C. Huston
- It's Just Like His Great LoveEdna R. Worrwell
- Ivory PalacesHenry Barraclough
